2024-03-29T17:19:33Z
https://journal.cesir.ir/?_action=export&rf=summon&issue=14163
Iranian Journal of Comparative Education
IJCE
2588-7270
2588-7270
2019
2
2
How the Japanese Teacher Preparation Programs for Secondary Teachers Have Been Shaped Since the Meiji Period
Takeyu
Ueyama
Japan took the initiatives to build the modern school system in 1872. The process of the building is characterized as the words like rapid, sometimes bold, and often tumbling in the economy, internal and external political conflicts and ideological conflicts. It is not difficult to realize how various values and beliefs have been intervening in the process, but not easy to lucidly observe them. The purpose of this study is to rediscover the cultural values and beliefs affecting the directions of teacher preparation programs for secondary school teachers in Japan. This study is a qualitative study, mainly analyzing the historical studies done by other researchers. It examined the development of teacher preparation programs from the late 19th century to the present day. Two different aspects were adapted for analysis: The concept of ‘program’ developed by Ueyama (2009), and the historical functions of university defined as organization, institution and community (Gamage & Ueyama, 2012). This study discussed in the four areas of development of the teacher preparation programs: national policy, preparation at the university level, the program structure and content, and quality teacher. It concluded what values were underlined and by what and how they were influenced in the process of shaping the teacher preparation for secondary school teachers.
Historical Analysis
Meiji Period
secondary teachers
Japan
2019
05
01
116
153
https://journal.cesir.ir/article_103667_ec63945fbafb79dcb0b7aae76b2147b4.pdf
Iranian Journal of Comparative Education
IJCE
2588-7270
2588-7270
2019
2
2
Nationalism and the Construction of Modern Education in Iran and Turkey: A Comparative Study
Hojjat
Heidari
Saeed
Saffarheidari
Nationalism, a modern sociopolitical phenomenon, bears a close connection with the rise of modern educational institutions. Additionally, modern educational institutions, in line with the ideology of nationalism, take upon themselves to consolidate ethnic and cultural diversities and transform them into a solid national identity in order to constitute the nation as a political unit. This article aims to survey the role of modern educational institutions in constructing a shared national identity. The present article, employing a comparative-historical analysis, will shed light on how modern nation-states were constituted in Iran and Turkey. Ultimately, based on theory of nationalism by Ernest Gellner (1925-1995) the results of the study indicated that both in Iran and Turkey, the notion of nation was fabricated via the nationalist ideology. Thus, in both countries, the educational institutions, which were in charge of political forces, did their best to help the state in order to build a homogenous nation.
Education
nationalism
modernism
State-nation
Iran
Turkey
2019
05
01
154
176
https://journal.cesir.ir/article_103668_fc6089240562ed13147a1a9891e78593.pdf
Iranian Journal of Comparative Education
IJCE
2588-7270
2588-7270
2019
2
2
A Comparative Study of Factors Contributing to Reading Comprehension in L2 (English) Among Iranian and Indian Students
Mojtaba
Maghsoudi
Abolfazl
Khodamoradi
Seyed Hassan
Talebi
Few studies have ever been conducted to find out degree of contribution of L1 reading ability and L2 general linguistic proficiency to L2 reading regarding the context of learning. Two groups of students from the Indian ESL (English as a Second Language) and Iranian English as a Foreign Language (EFL) contexts attended this study. Measures of general English proficiency (GEP), reading comprehension (RC) in L2 and reading strategy awareness (RSA) in L1 were administered among the participants. Findings showed that RSA accounted for 41% and 10% of variance in L2 RC for the Iranian and Indian groups, respectively. It was also found regression weight for RSA is still significant for the Iranian group but not for the Indian group. In addition, for the Iranian group, both RSA and GEP are significant variables in prediction of RC in L2 but for the Indian group only GEP contributed significantly to the prediction of RC in L2. In addition, for both the high and low Iranian GEP groups only the contribution of RSA was significant in the prediction of RC in L2. However, for the Indian group the role of RSA was insignificant in predicting RC in L2, for both high and low groups. As the differences of the findings are more than the similarities in the two contexts, it is suggested that reading teachers reconsider the significant role of factors that contribute more to L2 reading, regarding the moderating role that context of learning plays in this regard.
L1 reading
L2 reading
L2 proficiency
EFL Context
ESL context
2019
05
01
177
206
https://journal.cesir.ir/article_103669_6d9593bbc800381b7ce579db5a0d1518.pdf
Iranian Journal of Comparative Education
IJCE
2588-7270
2588-7270
2019
2
2
Comparative Analysis of Math Curriculum in 4th Grade of Primary Education in Iran with the Pioneer Countries of TIMSS
Maryam
Kian
Reyhaneh
Danaei Zarchi
Ahmad
Zandvanian Naeini
Performance of primary students in mathematics among the countries participating in TIMSS is different. The purpose of this study is to compare the math curriculum of Iran with the five countries which were the pioneers in TIMSS 2015 (Singapore, Hong Kong, South Korea, Taiwan, and Japan). The research method was comparative and the statistical population consisted of all math books of the fourth grade in Iran and the leading countries. The findings showed that some elements are similar among the countries, such as the concepts of numbers, calculation, measurement, and geometry. However, the studied curricula are different from each other, regarding skill of math problem solving, analysis and application of mathematical topics, interesting statistics and algebra topics, and positive attitude to math learning, so that in Iran these areas have been somewhat neglected. At the end, some suggestions were offered based on the findings.
comparative study
Math Curriculum
Primary Education
TIMSS
2019
05
01
207
229
https://journal.cesir.ir/article_103670_4dd7f1ef96bfd19a8744be96c4f38543.pdf
Iranian Journal of Comparative Education
IJCE
2588-7270
2588-7270
2019
2
2
Content Analysis of Farsi Textbooks of iranian general education Based on the Level of Attention to World Literature; A Comparative Approach
Rasul
Heydari
World literature in its various forms enhances understanding and mutual understanding and forms a "common language" between humans. Educational systems, in particular through formal programs and textbooks, can educate learners with the literature of the world, a generation of peace-loving and human-friendly people. On the basis of this idea, in this study Persian textbooks of Iranian formal public education course have been studied using content analysis method and comparative method to determine the amount, nature and manner of presenting world literature in them. The findings of the study show that the authors of Persian books of primary school had less attention to the topic of "world literature" compared to the first and second high school. Also, in all three periods, among the different literary genres, there was a greater emphasis on the teaching of literature, rich literature, and less epic literature. Also, in terms of how authors of textbooks are presented, interfered with and misunderstood in world literature, the disruption of the material, the uncertainty of the authors of the literary works of the world, the inappropriate selection of works, and the vacuum of "History of World Literature" are shortcomings of Persian books.
Content Analysis. Comparative Literature
World Literature
Persian Lesson
2019
05
01
230
243
https://journal.cesir.ir/article_103671_5991a92db8d82fd46909cac9b286e574.pdf
Iranian Journal of Comparative Education
IJCE
2588-7270
2588-7270
2019
2
2
Challenges of Conducting Qualitative Research in the Iranian Higher Education: Voices from ELT Faculty Members
Hossein
Bakhshi
Hiwa
Weisi
Nouroddin
yousofi
The main objective of this paper is to explore the insights and experiences of ELT (English Language Teaching) faculty members regarding the challenges of conducting QR in the Iranian higher education context. This study is qualitative, with its data obtained from semi-structured interviews with 20 ELT faculty members to gain their standpoints regarding possible challenges faced in qualitative studies. For analyzing the collected data, the recorded interviews were transcribed and then the grounded theory approach was employed. The results showed that the main possible challenges of conducting QR from ELT faculty members’ perspectives consisted of the dominance of positivism in the Iranian higher education context, paper publication, absence of QR course in postgraduate ELT syllabus, interpretation and analysis of data, dedicating a long time conducting QR, and writing proficiency. Most of the participants of the present study believed that the main reason for QR underdevelopment in academic setting is the Iranian higher education policies, and some of them stated that professors’ professional tastes and personal interests determined the research trend in the Iran higher educationsystem
ELT
Faculty Members
Higher education
qualitative research
2019
05
01
244
278
https://journal.cesir.ir/article_103674_fa2a2b79ecb810b927f16d2a8edda9b8.pdf